TAX(ING) CONSEQUENCES OF MARRIAGE CONTRACTS

Getting married has implications for a couple’s finances and taxes. We look at different types of marriage contracts and what difference they make during a marriage and also when it ends in divorce or death.

A marriage contract, like any other contract, has concomitant legal and personal income tax consequences upon conclusion and termination of such a contract. Couples should seek guidance regarding the applicable consequences prior to commencing or terminating a marriage contract.

According to Statistics South Africa. 45.4% of divorces recorded in 2015 consisted of marriages that did not survive their tenth wedding anniversary.

 

Types of marriage contracts recognised in law

In South Africa, the Marriage Act recognises three types of marriages:

  1. Customary marriages celebrated according to indigenous African customary law
  2. Civil marriages performed by a government or civil official in accordance with the marriage laws
  3. Civil unions that recognise a marriage or union between two individuals of the same gender

 

Different marriage regimes and tax

Marriage in community of property (ICOP)

This contract is automatically conferred in law where the couple do not enter into an antenuptial contract prior to commencement of the marriage. An antenuptial contract details the regime that would apply to the assets and liabilities and their distribution in case of divorce or death.

Assets and liabilities held by each of the spouses prior to the marriage will be combined into a joint estate of the spouses. For tax purposes, SARS will regard each spouse as having an equal share in the joint estate and in any income, profit or loss flowing from the estate.

Marriage out of community of property (OCOP) with accrual

The nominal value(s) of the respective estates are declared at commencement of the marriage. The difference between the net increases in the value of the estates during the marriage will be divided equally between the spouses upon termination of the marriage. ln the example below, Spouse A’s estate increased by R500 O00 and Spouse B’s by R400 OOO. A smaller amount accrued to Spouse B’s estate and it therefore has a claim against Spouse A’s estate for half of the difference in accrual (i.e. R50 OOO).

For capital gains tax purposes, the accrual system does not result in a splitting of capital gains and losses between spouses. The spouse that owns the asset must therefore account for the capital gain or loss in respect of the disposal of the asset.

Marriage out of community of property with no accrual system

“What is yours, is yours, what is mine, is mine before and after the marriage” best describes this regime. Neither spouse will have a claim to any assets from the estate of the other, or to profit flowing from those assets.

 

Interplay of the definition of “spouse” for income tax and South African law

Common law marriages, also referred to as cohabitation or living together as a domestic partnership, are not recognised as legal relationships in South African law. Nonetheless, section 1 of the Income Tax Act defines spouses, for the purposes of that Act, as people who are married in accordance with the Marriage Act or according to religious rights or partners in a union that may be regarded as permanent. This suggests that a couple who have been cohabiting but have no intention of getting married are also “spouses” tor the purpose of the definition.

According to the definition in the Act, “spouse” means, “in relation to any person, a person who is the partner of that person–

  1. in a marriage or customary union recognised in terms of the laws of the Republic;
  2. in a union recognised as a marriage in accordance with the tenets of any religion; or
  3. in a same-sex or heterosexual union which the Commissioner is satisfied is intended to be permanent, and ‘married’, ‘husband’ or ‘wife’ shall be construed accordingly: Provided that a marriage or union contemplated in paragraph (b) or (c) shall, in the absence of proof to the contrary, be deemed to be a marriage or union out of community of property;

 

Implications of marriage contracts for taxation purposes

The annual income return (ITR12) requires a taxpayer to indicate his or her marital status,

  • Not Married
  • Married in Community of Property
  • Married out of Community of Property

Taxpayers, whether married or unmarried, file tax returns separately. In this regard, remuneration for services rendered is included in the taxable income of the spouse who rendered the service.

 

Tax relief for transactions between spouses

Donations tax: Exemption exists in respect of donations between spouses.

Transfer duty: Not applicable to transfer of property upon death or divorce.

Estate duty: Not applicable in respect of bequest of assets.

Capital gains tax: Roll-over provisions in respect of the disposal of an asset. Recipient spouse is deemed to acquire the asset to a value equal to the base cost of the disposing spouse.

 

Tax consequences flowing from divorce orders

The divorce order should be reviewed regarding jointly held property, pension arrangements, alimony and maintenance. The ITR12 must also be updated.

Section 1O(1 )(u) of the Income Tax Act provides that any amount received by a spouse or ex-spouse by way of alimony or allowance or maintenance of such person under any judicial order, written agreement of separation or under any order of divorce, is exempt from normal tax. In this regard, the
settlement payment is not subject to tax.

Disposal of primary residence
Where the divorcing parties were married in community of property and owned and lived in a residence as their primary residence, the R2 million primary residence exclusion must be apportioned in relation to the parties‘ interest in the property. Each spouse may claim an exclusion up to R1 million if the property is sold.

Pension lump sum
The Pension Funds Amendment Act of 2007 provides that where a divorce order requires the payment of a pension fund lump sum to a non-member spouse before retirement, the member spouse can opt to take early withdrawal of part of the fund. The lump sum will be taxed in the hands of the non-member spouse as a withdrawal benefit. The non-member spouse may, however, transfer the lump sum to another equivalent fund without incurring an immediate withdrawal benefit tax liability.

Alimony and maintenance
Paragraph (b) of the gross income definition in section 1 of the Act requires that a receiving spouse include alimony or maintenance in their gross income. As specified above, section 1O(1)(u) of the Act provides an exemption. Accordingly, the receiving spouse does not pay tax on this amount and the paying spouse is not entitled to a deduction.

Given the South African legal landscape coupled with fiscal laws, it is evident that a contract constituted by a marriage, or aimed at regulating one, gives rise to personal tax implications. These implications should be considered before entering into a marriage contract and exiting a marriage.

Shohana Mohan, (2018). Tax(ing) Consequences of Marriage Contract, Taxtalk, (70), pp 28-29, South African Institute of Tax Professionals.

2019-11-08T18:02:26+00:00 November 8th, 2019|Articles|